Wednesday, November 23, 2022

Dr Mignini’s 360-Page Blockbuster Book Due To Be Released in One Month

Posted by Our Main Posters

1. Re The Book

Dr Mignini’s book will be released before Christmas by the University Of Perugia Press.

An English edition of the ultra-serious 360-page opus is in the works. We have not seen it yet, but we do understand that it closely mirrors and takes much further the general thrust of this page.

It follows hard on the heels of the Rudy Guede book which has just hammmered home that:

(1) all courts ruled that it had to have been a three-person attack (this was largely based on autopsy and situational evidence and a whole-day reconstruction PRESENTED IN CLOSED COURT);

(2) Knox & Sollecito were definitely at the scene of the crime; there was not a single scrap of evidence that anyone else was.

Not something unknown to every single Italian, but a useful time for it to be hammered home.

2. Re The Case

It seems all Italy is heartily sick of being globally impugned for a fine and fair legal process which was repeatedly illegally undermined. Sollecito’s appeal for damages was caustically shot down; tellingly, Knox did not even apply. 

The 2015 Supreme Court findings and verdict were nonsense, probably deliberately so to hint at pressures applied. In their report, the Fifth Chambers made clear that new evidence could render their verdict null and void.

The new evidence is of course the small mountain which the Fifth Chambers chose to ignore.

The President of the Republic and the Italian Supreme Court can each order a reopening of the case and a repeat of the final appeal.

The initiative is said to already have support within Parliament, Cassation, the Ministry of Justice, and the Council of Magistrates.

It is clearly likely to be huge, and could ripple on for years. Knox & Sollecito, their parents, their lawyers, their PR, and others in Italy could find themselves caught up in the net.

Maybe even more in the US: Preston, Ciolino, Moore, Fischer, Heavey, Burleigh, Hampikian, and a dozen others might find diffamazione targets on their backs.

Sollecio and his shadow writer Gumbel already lost a diffamazione trial, in Florence, that cost them big fines, and Knox lost a calunnia trial in Perugia, which cost her three years and huge damages owed to Patrick (still unpaid).

It’s strongly recommended that you check out the 2015 Cassation critiques in our right column and especially (in this order) the critiques of the Prosecution, of Machiavelli, and of James Raper, who may all be having a very nice day.

Posted by Our Main Posters on 11/23/22 at 12:42 PM in

Tweet This Post


Dr Mignini is perhaps the best connected prosecutor in Italy and most popular on TV due to this case and also to his academic and anti-mafia and Monster of Florence work.

Today, in fact, he is delivering a report on the MOF case to the anti-mafia taskforce of the lower house of Parliament, called the Chamber of Deputies.

Ii is typical of Italian mafia cases that the evidence is quietly assembled for years, and then suddenly - bam!! - three hundred people are in court. Sicily saw several of those. Milan had one.

Dr Mignini has been a major player in such processes at least twice: once leading up to a big trial in Perugia, and once leading up to the current VERY big trial in western Calabria.

Posted by Peter Quennell on 11/23/22 at 05:50 PM | #

Meanwhile in Montreal Sollecito’s mafioso Uncle Rocco (RIP) has been in the news.

The trial had begun recently of alleged shooter Jonathan Massari, when suddenly for reasons unannounced a mistrial was declared.

Stay tuned. The Canadians will find a way, perhaps with Italian help, to make the jurors at a new trial feel safe.

Posted by Peter Quennell on 11/23/22 at 06:51 PM | #

I wonder how much of Mignini’s 360 page book is autobiographical and how much of it will actually deal with the Kercher case. We shall see.

As to Guede’s self published kindle book in Italian entitled “A Reasonable Doubt” this is very short at 144 pages. Usually you get to see the first 10% as a preview but Kindle aren’t allowing this at the moment. I expect it to give some of his background and a description of his time in prison and so what he has to say about the case may be fairly limited, and that to be mostly a rehash of what he said in statements and testimony in court. I don’t expect any surprises.

Posted by James Raper on 11/24/22 at 10:22 AM | #

GM is setting out to vindicate Italian justice and I dont get a sense that it is an autobiography. He has done lots of YouTubes in which he never really talks about himself in personal terms. I’d say his book will be about as dense as your excellent book but with more on the bad guys. 😊

Guede’s book is summarized in online reviews in Italian including those on Amazon Italy and it does seem pretty introspective, explaining his lifetime arc with some major regrets, though it’s not a full confession of having been proactive in Meredith’s murder.

We carried his RAI YouTubes (which seemingly pointed to RS & AK more-so) but also oiur own scathing reports on his denials in his appeal late in 2009. Also the total chaos he and Alessi and Aviello caused at the Hellman appeal, with Bongiorno and Hellman having conniptions.

Posted by Peter Quennell on 11/24/22 at 11:46 AM | #

A pro-Knox YouTube apologist asked what the reopening of the case in 2023 could achieve. The response posted was this.

Confirmation of the Nencini verdict. Italy cannot last in this nasty limbo forever. It has one of the best police & judicial systems in the world, and hosts THREE UN centers of excellence. All the lawyers thought RS & AK did it. Open secret in Perugia. RS lawyers both implied at trial AK led the pack. RS & AK have fought like dogs almost ever since, we list 35 incidents in a very funny post. RS’s book title is a jab at Knox. Both Knox & RS books were huge mistakes, in sustaining an open wound. RS lost badly at diffamazione trial (also Gumbel) to GM, for false claims, and had to pay huge damages. AK can still be sued for her book, GM just met her and gave her a chance to withdraw. Knox was actually pretty happy in prison, her mental condition (probably caused by her dad) was coming right. Now, she barely knows up from down - as GM just saw.

Posted by Peter Quennell on 11/25/22 at 07:01 PM | #

Tweet This Post

Post A Comment


Where next:

Click here to return to The Top Of The Front Page

Or to previous entry In Strong Similarity To Perugia, Student Deaths Send US Campus Town Reeling