Category: The wider contexts
The Italian Tanker Is Still Held In South India Pending… Not Clear Precisely What
Posted by Peter Quennell
Our previous post described an Italian tanker held and two Italian soldiers in custody for shooting two Indian fishermen they thought were pirates.
Several times since. it seemed that whatever evidence can be assembled would be unveiled preparatory to a trial, the Italian crew would explain fully what happened, the soldiers might be charged, and the ship released to go on its way once the Italian owners paid a large bond - which, a while back, they did.
But lawyers acting for the family of one of the fishermen at the last moment sued to stop the ship on the point of leaving because they claimed they did not trust the owners to pay up - even despite the bond having been lodged in the amount (30 million rupees) that the family itself had demanded.
Now tempers seem to be rising in all directions, and as Sreedhar Pillai observes it is not simply Italy v India.
What has been most surprising is the appalling way both countries have handled the sensitive issue, each one not without its own hidden compulsions, and the public stance each country was obliged to take.
For the new Italian Prime minister Mario Monti , there were more compelling matters to attend… However the way the Italians have come out without a convincing and straightforward explanation of what happened has not helped the matter or enabled the Indians to react helpfully to solve the issue.
Besides, the Italian authorities have also failed to grasp the political compulsions under which the Indian government had to act in this matter.
For a start, Kerala, which is the last place people still believe in communism, has a party which lost the recent election with slim margin and has an interest to politicize every issue in order to win a crucial local election held in March. The ruling congress party with slim majority and allegations of corruption with the central government which they lead couldn’t afford to let the legal path take its own course.
That Kerala has a sizable Catholic population didn’t help, with Kerala Bishops facing accusation of taking up for a Catholic foreign country.
Although never mentioned publicly, the most sensitive reason for the stiff Indian stance is nothing but the Italian origin of Sonia Gandhi, presiding over the Congress Party, currently ruling India and several states including Kerala as the major coalition partner.
Hmmm. So in the Italian media one can now find hard comments like “the ship was trying to avoid piracy, but seems to have wandered into it anyway” and in the Indian media one can find comments ranging from “hang the murderers” to “the lawyers for the family are being opportunist”.
Today it is announced that the soldiers are remanded without charges for yet another 14 days. Meanwhile the owners of the Enrica Lexie have sued at the Indian Supreme Court level to get their ship back.
We may hear whether this is agreed to tomorrow. Sadly, the real pirates at the root of all this must be laughing.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 04/16/12 at 04:07 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The legal followups, The wider contexts, Italian context •
Comments here (7)
In Close Parallel To Amanda Knox, Casey Anthony Faces Court Action For Falsely Fingering Another
Posted by Peter Quennell
Both recent images. Above the plaintiff Zenaida Gonzalez; below the defendant Casey Anthony
Amanda Knox provisionally got off on the main count (the murder of Meredith) but anyway was sentenced to three years (which she served) for fingering Patrick Lumumba.
Casey Anthony definitively got off on the main count (murdering her infant daughter Caylee, see previous posts) but anyway was sentenced to some time in prison for time-wasting and expensive misleading of the police officers.
She received no sentence for falsely fingering a nanny, Zenaida Gonzalez, for making off with Caylee, and as she had never even met Zenaida Gonzalez it is unclear how she came up with Zenaida’s name.
The Orlando Sentinel reports an issue is whether or not Anthony identified Gonzalez specifically enough when she talked to her parents when they visited her in jail.
Anthony’s attorney said details offered by Anthony did not match Fernandez-Gonzalez and clearly showed Anthony wasn’t talking about her. Gonzalez’s attorneys say she still was damaged as the only person with that name interviewed by investigators.
Fernandez-Gonzalez had never met Anthony. Investigators believe Anthony may have seen the name on an apartment rental application.
During Anthony’s trial last year, her attorney Jose Baez said Anthony made up the story about the babysitter and that Caylee truly drowned in the family pool. Anthony was acquitted of murder and other serious charges.
Nevertheless, yesterday a judge in Orlando, Florida, ruled that Zenaida Gonzalez may sue Casey Anthony for defamation of character, and the case is scheduled for January 2013.
In Amanda Knox’s case she absolutely did know Patrick Lumumba, her kindly employer who gave her a job without a work permit, and she and her mother let him languish in prison for several weeks.
Pretty hard to look worse than Casey Anthony, but in her cruel act of framing Patrick, Amanda Knox certainly does.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 04/13/12 at 06:28 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in Various hypotheses, Pondering motive, The psychology, The judical timeline, The legal followups, The wider contexts, N America context •
Comments here (2)
The Irony In A Legal Standoff Between Italy And (Normally Its Good Friend) India
Posted by Peter Quennell
[Above: Cantilevered fishing nets. There are hundreds of these along the ocean shore and harbor of Kochi.]
Images here are of the beautiful and comparatively wealthy south-west India city of Cochin (Kochi).
Also of an Italian oil tanker, the Enrica Lexie, which was ordered into the Kochi port mid-February by the Indian coastguard. Two Italian marine snipers guarding the tanker en route from Singapore to Egypt had shot two Indian fishermen on a small tuna boat assuming they were pirates.
The marines do seem to have been rather quick on the draw, and in contravention of a new IMO law of the sea saying violence during such incidents must be kept to a minimum. The tanker had apparently already been attacked once that day; shots had apparently been fired then too.
Indian accounts say India has behaved reasonably. The incident was in an area the Indian navy makes a serious effort to keep safe (images also below) even though most ships cruising along the busy sea-lane off Kochi (map below) don’t touch base in India and provide no benefit to the Indian economy.
The Italian tanker has been released now and is on its way, but the two Italian marines are still under house arrest in the house shown below, while a discussion between the two governments continues over where they should be put on trial.
The Italian government is arguing that as the marines are military personnel therefore Italian military law trumps Indian civil law and they must be put on trial in Italy.
Okay. Now for the irony. Read the posts here and here. The US government made the same argument twice against Italy, and to say the least Italy was not too happy.
Pssst. Don’t tell India.
At bottom: Another Italian ship in trouble in the Indian Ocean. This is the fire-stricken Carnival cruise line ship Costa Allegra (yes that Carnival cruise line) unloading its disconsolate passengers in the Seychelles.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 03/02/12 at 05:02 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The judical timeline, The legal followups, The wider contexts, Italian context •
Comments here (11)
Costa Concordia: Amid Continuing Environmental Concerns The Captain Is Charged With More
Posted by Peter Quennell
The death toll has now risen to 25 including one child, a little girl. Maybe 10 are still unaccounted for.
The ship turns out to be balancing precariously on two small castles of rock at its front and back ends and they now seem to be decomposing under the ship’s colossal weight.
Whether the fuel oil can be removed from the ship before it disappears into deeper waters in a very fragile marine environment now seems anyone’s guess. Technically the engineers seem to be doing all they can.
The Genoa-based Carnival subsidiary seems to have closed ranks again as its own top management behavior comes under investigation. Nick Squires of the Daily Telegraph has just reported this from a session of the Grosseto court.
Prosecutors allege that the captain’s negligence and misconduct were compounded by errors made by senior officials from Costa Cruises, the Italian company that owns the ship.
They have broadened their investigation to include three Costa Cruises employees, including Manfred Ursprunger, the vice-president, and Roberto Ferrarini, the head of the company’s crisis management unit.
He was in regular contact with the skipper on the night of the disaster but prosecutors accuse him of being “culpably unaware of the real situation on board the ship” and of falling to verify the information provided by Capt Schettino.
Nick Squires also reports that Captain Schettino’s legal prospects have now worsened.
On Thursday, prosecutors lodged two new charges against the captain, accusing him of abandoning incapacitated passengers and failing to inform the coast guard in Livorno, on the mainland, of what was happening on the ship.
He was already charged with abandoning ship, causing a disaster and multiple counts of manslaughter and is under house arrest at his home near Sorrento, south of Naples.
Nick Squires also reports on how the ship was slowed down to allow the captain and his lady friend to finish their meal. Then it was speeded up to awe someone in Giglio, and a big crowd on the ship’s bridge.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 02/24/12 at 08:57 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The judical timeline, The legal followups, Italian related, The wider contexts, Italian context •
Comments here (9)
The Learning Experiences Emerging From The Carnival Ship Disaster Off Italy’s West Coast
Posted by Peter Quennell
Value migrations force better systems upon us, and so the human race progresses…
Check out first what seems to be happening to value as a result of the Costa Concordia wreck, as reflected in the stockmarket chart just below. Stockmarkets and currency exchange rates constitute the value votes of a lot of watchful people trying to decide where to put their money.
Italy has no independent currency any more, so Italy sorely lacks that other very useful value indicator and safety valve. But stockmarket behavior is telling us a lot both about Italy and about the Carnival cruise line.
In the past three months during which the main American index, the Dow-Jones (red curve), gained an okay 8 percent, the Italian stockmarket index (green curve) gained a very impressive 30 percent.
The main news out of Italy in those three months was (1) the austerity plan, which in theory is setting the stage for future growth (toward which there was some cynicism), and (2) the recovery from the wreck of the Costa Concordia (toward which the doubts were even greater).
You can see a slight blip down in the green curve immediately after the wreck, but then Italy continued with speedy value migration inward. It seems fair to say “Well done Italy. You’ve received votes of international confidence on both fronts.”
Carnival, however, rather less-so.. The blue curve is the stock price of Carnival Cruise Lines and it’s still down about 12 percent since the wreck happened which is about $3 billion off Carnival’s market valuation. All cruise lines seem to have taken something of a hit and are likely to encounter other heat to make sure they all keep improving.
Check out now what is happening to systems.
It seems clear that the captain was steering the ship while he was a bit tiddly while showing off to what increasingly appears to have been his girlfriend by his side. By international and Carnival rules (1) the captain should not have been drinking, (2) he should not have been five miles off course, (3) the Moldovan dancer should not have been on the bridge, and (4) the captain should have been a lot more careful in his navigating.
So four systems at least were violated.
Then when the ship was beached - there is some uncertainty as to whether this was deliberate or whether the captain was just putting the ship in shallow water - (5) damage to ship bulkheads was much more than expected, adding to the high number of deaths, (6) the lifeboats were almost impossible to launch, and (7) the evacuation procedures almost totally broke down - in part because there had been no evacuation drill before the ship left the port of Rome, and in part because the captain went awol and was already standing on the beach.
That is far from an exhaustive list and systems changes implemented after the 9/11 attack numbered up in the hundreds - military responses, building techniques, city preparedness, corporate distribution of their people and physical assets. We will see the same happen here.
Right now we are watching what appear to be two very efficient systems cutting in and doing their work. One is the recovery of the oil from the ship and then the ship itself. And the other is the Italian legal system, which is going to be kept busy with this one for years.
There is increasing evidence that the single Moldovan dancer and the married captain were having some sort of affair. She briefly admitted as much, telling a court she loved him, and the searchers and divers may have found her effects in his cabin.
He may now face 2,500 years in prison to reflect on the importance of respecting systems and the value of peoples’ lives. .
Posted by Peter Quennell on 02/10/12 at 05:31 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The judical timeline, The legal followups, The wider contexts, Italian context •
Comments here (9)
Did The Captain Being Drunk Delay Evacuation And Cause The Probable 30-Plus Deaths?
Posted by Peter Quennell
[Above: the passengers and apparently somewhere here the captain standing on Port Giglio’s beach at midnight]
Airline pilots have been accused of drunk flying and the worst incident seems to have caused 88 deaths.
Systems changes were implemented to try to stop this ever happening again. We may now be about to see the same thing happen in the cruise ship industry. There are multiple Italian and UK reports that in the two hour period after the ship left the port of Rome, the captain drank maybe a whole carafe of wine, and became distinctly the worse for wear.
Survivors from the shipwreck have claimed that when the ship’s captain, Francesco Schettino, stood up from his table in the ship’s exclusive Club Concordia restaurant, approximately half an hour before the ship ran on to the rocks, he was in a particularly jolly mood.
La Repubblica suggests that Capt Schettino (52) was not in a fit state to drive a moped let alone pilot a 114,000-tonne cruiser, asserting he would almost certainly have failed a breathalyser test.
The Wall Street Journal reported this bizarre claim from a cook.
About a half-hour after the ship struck the rock…Rogelio Barista, the ship’s cook, said he and other kitchen staff members spotted the captain and a woman ordering food, including drinks and dessert””a sign of apparent nonchalance that left kitchen staff puzzled.
“I asked myself why he was still there waiting for his companion’s dessert with what was happening,” Mr. Barista said in an interview with Italian television.
The Associated Press reported the confusion caused for the shipping company, crew and passengers as a seeming direct result:
The cruise captain who grounded the Costa Concordia off the Tuscan coast with 4,200 people on board did not relay correct information either to the company or crew after the ship hit rocks, the cruise ship owner’s CEO said Friday as the search resumed for 21 missing passengers.
CEO Pierluigi Foschi told Italian state TV that the company spoke to the captain at 10:05 p.m. some 20 minutes after the ship ran aground on Jan. 13, but could not offer proper assistance because the captain’s description “did not correspond to the truth.”
Capt. Francesco Schettino said only that he had “problems” on board but did not mention hitting a reef. Likewise, Foschi said crew members were not informed of the gravity of the situation. Passenger video shown on Italian TV indicates crew members telling passengers to go to their cabins as late as 10:25 p.m. The abandon ship alarm sounded just before 11:00 p.m.
“That’s because they also did not receive correct information on the gravity of the situation,” Foschi said.
In the most cutting English-language report, the Daily Mail claims that the presence of the Moldovan dancer alongside the captain seemingly throughout may have played a deadly role.
And that the very extensive delay in evacuating the ship may have cost all or most of the 30-plus lives lost - most of those still missing are believed to have jumped into the cold sea.
Costa’s president Pierluigi Foschi admitted in an interview with Italian newspaper Corriere Della Serra yesterday, that the alarm had been raised too late by Schettino.
“˜Too late. I can’t sleep at night. If we had abandoned it earlier then we would not have lost any lives.’
He said Schettino had always been considered “˜technically able’ but had “˜character issues’. “˜He liked to be at the centre of it.’
The company has now announced it will not pay the captain’s legal fees. Although cruise ships are already very safe, mandatory system change at ship and company levels seem in store. Hopefully including compulsory brain scans of captains and all top crew.
Yesterday the captain finally - finally - expressed some contrition. The sad tales of the dead including a six year old girl are only now starting to come out.
Below: The Concordia, the first supersized Carnival ship, was built in Palermo Sicily in this yard in 2006.
Below: The ship headed out of Rome’s port (Civitavecchia) about two hours before it hit the rocks.
Below: The route the cruise ship was to take. Its unauthorized cruise by Giglio was several miles off authorized course.
Below: The ship hit the rocks at bottom and tilted to the left as it took on water, and is seemingly deliberately beached.
Below: The La Scole rocks (which are not a reef) which the ship hit; there is still confusion over its precise course.
Below: Various charts seem to show all the rocks correctly, and also very deep water a few meters to the east.
Below: The ship picked up the rock that it hit and the rock can be seen here still embedded in the side.
Below: The ship as it was yesterday precariously perched on the highest of several underwater shelves.
Below: The search divers are mostly Carabinieri. Most lost bodies are probably down in very deep water.
Below: The captain is confined to his home in this town across the bay from Naples and Vesuvius to the left.
Below: The captain’s house. Reporters are hanging around outside to record him, but he has not emerged.
Below: One of Carnival Cruise Corp’s two global headquarters, this is in Miami; the other is in London
Below: US Carnival Cruise Corp President and CEO Christine Duffy wants a global cruise systems review
Below: Carnival’s current market capitalization ($24 billion) seems low, but in recent years its stock (blue curve) beat the US average.
Below: Carnival’s stock (blue curve) has not been so hot in recent weeks; it just dropped $4-5 billion.
Below: The UN’s International Maritime Org in London where global maritime systems are agreed.
Below: A BBC animation that aired last monday on what happened to the ship on the night..
Posted by Peter Quennell on 01/21/12 at 03:20 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The legal followups, The wider contexts, Italian context •
Comments here (39)
Italy Hails An Unlikely Hero Who Tried To Talk The Captain Back On The Ship He Abandoned
Posted by Peter Quennell
You probably already know the broad outline of this story.
Last Friday the Carnival cruise ship Costa Concordia ran onto some rocks by an island off the west coast of Italy and it semi-capsized. Some 35 passengers are declared dead or missing, the ship could slide further or sink any time, and the fuel-oil is all still on board.
This video is the BBC’s translation of the coastguard captain Gregorio De Falco (left below) trying to talk the cruise ship captain Francesco Schettino (right below) out of a lifeboat and back on board his ship to facilitate the rescue of the 4,000 passengers and crew.
Captain De Falco is not mincing any words. It seems that Italians cannot get enough of that stern talk. The tape is being played again and again on Italian radio and TV with Captain De Falco being likened to various great Italian leaders of the past - and Captain Schettino to the vain and ultimately disastrous Mr Berlusconi.
This report is from American National Public Radio.
“You’ve abandoned ship! I’m in charge now,” De Falco rages at Schettino, who was apparently in a rowboat at this time. “Go back and report to me how many passengers [are still onboard] and what they need. ... Perhaps you saved yourself from the sea, but I’ll make you pay for this, dammit!”
Schettino can be heard trying to refuse the order. “You don’t understand, it’s dark here. Can’t see anything,” he says. “What is it, you want to go home Schettino?” De Falco spits out. “It’s dark and you want to go home?” Eventually De Falco demands: “Go back onboard, dammit!”
De Falco’s Italian expletive is actually much harsher than “dammit” “” but the line [“Torni a bordo, cazzo!”] has become a national catchphrase, and is Italy’s top trending hashtag or keyword on Twitter.
Minutes after that audio was posted online, Italians had a new hero. Within hours, a Facebook page created in De Falco’s name had 10,000 friends. By Wednesday morning, his words were a national slogan, with T-shirts being sold online with the words, “Go back onboard, dammit.”...
One tweet from a woman named Sofia Rosada said, “It’s men like De Falco who should be governing, instead we are full of men like Schettino.”
The governing politicians dithered and looked after their own main chance for far too long. But the various stories we have followed on this site have thrown up at professional levels a number of unlikely and unsung heroes.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 01/19/12 at 04:06 AM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The legal followups, The wider contexts, Italian context •
Comments here (13)
Norwegian Public Safety Forces Ill-Equipped To Stop Possible Worst Shooting Spree in History
Posted by Peter Quennell
The latest death toll estimate at Lake Utoya and Oslo is 98 dead. The gunman was firing for one and a half hours.
Apparently there was no security presence on the island. And the Associated Press has the first report on why such a delayed response from an under-equipped police force to stop Anders Behring Breivik from more killing.
Police arrived at an island massacre about 1.5 hours after a gunman first opened fire, slowed because they didn’t have quick access to a helicopter and then couldn’t find a boat to make their way to the scene just several hundred yards (meters) offshore.
There is a minute by minute description of the growing horror on the island here and a Norwegian politician has posted a first-hand account of how so many others died and she survived here.
Intensely sad and disturbing - and in the land of the Nobel Peace Prize. We don’t support public institutions at our real peril.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 07/23/11 at 11:40 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The legal followups, The wider contexts •
Comments here (4)
French Divided Over French Woman In Mexico Jail: Take A Hard Noisy Line Or One Quiet And Subtle?
Posted by Peter Quennell
You’d be surprised - or maybe not - at how very rare it is that publicly impugning another country’s legitimacy and competence really pays off.
Good governments and good international lawyers and good public relations experts all very rapidly move to take negotiations quietly behind the scenes. Though that may not guarantee the outcome they want, it usually results in some wiggle room and softening.
But the opportunity for this passes very fast.
We have only ever seen a hard line out of the unblinking Italian courts in Meredith’s case, up to and including the Supreme Court of Cassation in their rejection of Guede’s final appeal. The hardline PR seems to have hit a wall. And Amanda Knox (in the calunnia trial) and her biological parents (in theirs) and the family of Raffaele Sollecito (in their perversion of justice trial) all seem to have hit their own individual walls.
It is hard to see what the hardline PR campaign for Amanda Knox has achieved other than that equal and opposite Italian hard line. After a very silly start the Knox family legal advisor Ted Simon seems to have tried to get away from all that, and to move things behind closed doors.
Florence Cassez’s case is very well described in the Wikipedia entry.
Now 36, she moved to Mexico from France in 2003, ended up with a Mexican boyfriend who was decidedly bad news, and in December 2005 was arrested for her part in kidnapping three people for ransom.
Kidnapping is huge in Mexico, and along with the wars over the supplying of Americans with drugs, it comes top of most people’s most-feared list.
In line with the Mexican government’s efforts to try to stamp out all the kidnapping, Florence Cassez was given a very harsh sentence. It is now set at 60 years. There are dozens of French and Spanish-language reports and YouTubes on the case.
She has had one appeal which failed and right now she serves out her 60 years.
Almost without exception, Mexicans feel it was a well-proven case and that Florence Cassez’s claims that she did not not know what was going on right under her nose when three captives were being held by her boyfriend on the same ranch rang hollow at her trial.
France has been more divided.
There are some who think she did it and must pay the piper for her crime. There are some who think a softer line might have helped. And there are some, like President Sarkozy, who have taken a very hard line. They seem to have upset Mexico’s president and senior officials and not influenced the judges at all.
France has no sentence longer than 20 years for kidnapping-related crimes so the Mexican government has closed the door to her returning to France and serving out her sentence in prison there.
After more time passes and presidential elections happen in Mexico and France, the deadlock might be broken, and the case could be reviewed and Florence Cassez’s fate become something different.
But for now she has only her “friends” to thank.
Below: two of the few videos with English commentary or subtitles, both pro-Florence Cassez, the first some years old, and the second early this year.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 07/21/11 at 04:28 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The legal followups, The wider contexts •
Comments here (9)
Jennifer Ford Is The First Juror To Speak Out On The Casey Anthony Acquittal
Posted by Peter Quennell
Posted by Peter Quennell on 07/08/11 at 03:30 PM •
Permalink for this post •
Archived in The judical timeline, The legal followups, The wider contexts, N America context •
Comments here (3)